Showing posts with label law and politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label law and politics. Show all posts

Thursday, 26 February 2009

Sir Fred Goodwin

RBS agreed to pay him the pension. He is contractually entitled to it. (Addition: yes, an element was a discretionary payment, but the decision was taken to pay it, and under his contract, he is entitled to it.)

So, putting aside the fact that a court case to stop it being paid out would have no hope of success, why do any decent and reasonable people support government efforts to bully him into giving it up with threats of legal action?

Addition: this isn't a comment on the morality of Goodwin's position. It might well be that the right thing for him to do would be to give up some or all of the pension. But that's not a reason for the Government to harass him. It would be morally right for me to give 30% of my salary to Oxfam, but I don't, and I don't want the Minister for Overseas Development to leave me messages badgering me to do so.

Update: Prescott on Today tells us that RBS should stop paying the pension and wait for Goodwin to sue. Brilliant. He would sue, he would win, and so on top of the pension, substantial court costs would have to be paid. What a twat.

Thursday, 19 February 2009

Should Jacqui Smith be disappointed about Abu Qatada?

In the car today, Red Harriet - occasional blogger at JMP and glamorous siren - became annoyed at Radio 4 reporting that Jacqui Smith was 'disappointed' by the decision of the European Court to award Abu 'a truly dangerous individual' Qatada £2,500 compensation for his being detained without trial under the 2001 Anti-Terrorism, Crime and Security Act.

Her annoyance sprang not from the rightness or otherwise of the decision, but rather the appropriateness of the Home Secretary expressing disappointment about it. In her view, it is not right for a politician, let alone a Government Minister, to suggest that a court has got something wrong - unless it is in the appeal court. In her view, a better response would have been along the lines of 'we do not share the view that Mr Qatada should be awarded compensation, but we respect the court's decision'.

I don't share this view. I don't understand it all as regards the European Court, where the British government has no meaningful power over it. As regards British courts, the separation of powers means, I think, that it is not improper for the government to say that it thinks a court's decision is wrong, even that it is 'scandalous' (as the Conservatives described today's decision). What is clearly wrong, in my view, is where politicians attack individual judges, as with the vile David Blunkett, whose shameful bullying was apparently the cause of Lord Woolf's early retirement as Lord Chief Justice. That risks being seen as attempted interference with justice by the executive.

Incidentally, while it may be good politics, it is almost always stupid in legal and logical terms for politicians to attack the court's decision. The courts very rarely apply the law wrongly. The correct subject of the attack is normally the law itself. But, of course, that is nominally within the power of the government to change, so it is much easier to attack the judgment than the statute it applies. 

PS If you want to read a cretinous, disingenuous, extraordinarily ill-informed and almost parodically hand-wringingly liberal discussion of the decision finally to deport Qatada, feel free to head over to Victoria Brittain's recent piece on CiF. It's all about 'casual racism', you know. FFS.